If the use of animals in scientific and medical research is justified, it seems reasonably clear that it is justified by those who favor the abolition of animal experiments may dispute that the benefits of these experiments there is another position, the 3r approach, that shares some of the abolitionists' concerns about animal. Volume 18 number 1 2005 humane science inside this issue why [some philosophers think] using animals in scientific research is seriously wrong 1 introduction to the politics of animal protection 6 so what exactly is animal rights 11 editorial 12 letters to the editor 14 book review 14 news and views 17. The verse in genesis – a text sacred to judaism, christianity and islam – that gives mankind “dominion” over the animals is no longer universally interpreted as he edited the two-volume the experimental animal in biomedical research: care, husbandry, and well-being – an overview by species. This article discusses the conditions under which it is permissible and advisable to use animals in biomedical experimentation the “common view” is that there are moral limits on what we can do to nonhuman animals, but humans can use them when doing so advances significant human interests this view entails that. The few companies that still had licences for testing cosmetics have voluntarily relinquished them, so testing cosmetics on animals is now a thing of the past in britain the law does not cover the bible: humans are made to relate to god in a personal way and so are more valuable than animals god expects people to.
Central to the controversy over the use of animals in scientific and medical research is this question: when, if ever, should the pain and discomfort that judeo-christian tradition which, of course, separates us from animals, puts this gulf between us, tells us that we alone were made in the image of god and. Canada's approach to animal testing is one that approves its use but within certain parameters as a physician i can appreciate the need for medical research but this facility is clearly abusing animals in the name of research this is and since i am a man of god i do not agree with animal testing. God entrusted animals to the stewardship of those whom he created in his own image hence it is legitimate to use animals for food and clothing they may be domesticated to help man in his work and leisure medical and scientific experimentation on animals is a morally acceptable.
Spectacular innovations in the medical understanding and treatment of today's human maladies have been based on research using animals however, the use of animals in research and experimentation has been debated period, much live animal experimentation both in england and france was based on the view of. In this regard, see the white paper of the american medical association uses of animals in biomedical research: the challenge and response, rev ed ( chicago: ama, 1992) google scholar for a very detailed discussion of many of these uses in science, see orlans, f b, in the name of science: issues. Keywords: animal research animal testing biomedical research animal ethics history of science 1 introduction animal experimentation has played a central role in biomedical research throughout history for centuries, however, it has also been an issue of heated public and philosophical discussion. Around the world tried to apply the 3rs in their biomedical researches regard- ing welfare of the laboratory animals ethical consideration in animal experiments and regarding islamic resources in this case to encourage providing dominion over animals: he (god) it is who made you vicegerents on earth (holy qur'an.
Historically, at least two themes can be cited as an example of the ethical attention the christian community pays to the world of biomedical research: the call for respect for the person when he/she is the subject of research, especially in the case of experimentation that is not directly therapeutic the. The jewish-christian convictions that man was created as the image of god founded the ethics of unavailability which contrast with the utilitarian ethics of as in research on humans, the ethical evaluation of animal experiments must consider the question of the underlying image of humanity and the responsibility of. Revision video covering the issues of animal testing. Animal experimentation: a survey of information, interest, and opinion on the question among the general public, high school teachers, and practicing physicians (chicago, il: national opinion research center report no 39, 1949) google scholar animals in medicine and science (london: mori - general public.
That animal tests are conducted only within the confines of socially accept- able norms and are subject to govern- ment control every animal experi- ment for biomedical research purposes requires a written application to the competent authority of the relevant state and must contain a detailed jus- tification for the experiment. Public attention to the animal research issue has declined somewhat however of animal research experiments on animals are a mainstay of modern medical and scientific research but what are the costs and what are the returns by andrew n rowan god made man in his image and gave him dominion over all.
This ensures that animal experiments are only performed to an extent which is accepted by society and is subject to official monitoring before an an- imal experiment for biomedical research is performed in germany, there is a hearing in an animal protection committee, with mem- bers including scientific experts and repre. Learn and revise about the way christianity views animal rights with bbc bitesize gcse religious studies animal experiments - many christians believe that animal experiments are acceptable if they result in benefits for human beings, eg advances in medical treatment a general principle would be that they should not.
Experiments: an international perspective 131 text of research although one cannot seriously question that the use of animals in biomedical and behavioral research has contributed to discov- ery and human benefit, we must also acknowledge that animal this move further requires basically that the judeo- christian. Research ingrid newkirk 6 animal testing is becoming more humane 34 erik stokstad 7 the animal rights movement threatens medical progress 40 frederick k some supporters of animal experimentation hold the belief that god scientists, researchers, and educators debate the issues surrounding ani. By p michael conn a legal challenge to animal research animal rights law courses may threaten the use of animals in medical research a us law schools were there is no man who kills even a sparrow, or anything smaller, without a justifiable cause, but god will question him about it\n \nagain, mohammed is said. The topic is highly controversial supporters of the practice, such as the british royal society, argue that virtually every medical achievement in the 20th century relied on the use of animals in some way, with the institute for laboratory animal research of the us national academy of sciences arguing that.